The Rugby Football Club

 

 Rugby Lions Supporters Site

 

      
Best viewed 1024x768    
Home
Forum
Fixtures
Match Reports
Players
Colts
Mini & Junior
Past Seasons
History
Membership Benefits
Supporters Club
Links
Directions
Contact Us
                         

 

                  

 

NATIONAL DIVISION 1

LIONS 14 v 27

Manchester

at Webb Ellis Rd Link to Manchester's web site
on 22nd September Last season reports
ko 3.00pm Home Away
 
..
Match Report  By Don Townend, pictures Dave Rushall
© rugbylions.net commercial use of this report (modified or not) is strictly prohibited, unless written permission given by the webmaster.

Read Don's summary

 

Lions’ supporters came along today ready to back their team to the hilt despite the recent poor displays, but they were rewarded with yet another totally unacceptable performance that highlighted the ineptitude of the current management and coaching set up.  

Lions showed that the improvement we have been promised each week was still not forthcoming as they conspired to completely miss the first line-out.  Manchester gratefully accepted possession and set up their first attacking opportunity.  Luckily the excellent Matt Vines, who must be wondering what he has let himself in for, produced a try saving smother tackle on Craig Cooper as the Manchester centre went for the corner. 

However, it wasn’t long before Manchester were in front as they took good line-out possession and Lions were incapable of stopping the drive as lock David Jessiman broke from the maul to crash over.  Marcus Barrow pulled his conversion attempt well wide.  ( 0 – 5 ). 

A fine Matt Vines take from a high kick set up the Lions first attack.  A good kick to the corner by Jacques Steyne saw a hurried clearance retrieved by Stuart Potter who drove back deep into Manchester territory.  Lions swung the ball wide and good hands by Guy Manson-Bishop in the centre(!?!?!?!) almost had James Black away, but the winger was unable to take an overhead pass.  However, referee Alan Biggs recalled play for a Manchester offside, and Jason Critchley confidently stroked the penalty.  ( 3 – 5 ). 

Manchester again drove in hard, but were met by defiant Lions’ tackling with Jacques Steyne to the fore.  Lions were again indebted to Matt Vines as Manchester fly half John Broxson spotted the gap, but the Lions’ full back again made the all important tackle. 

Lions made an immediate reposte as a chip over the Manchester defence saw the flying James Baker almost take an awkward bounce.  However, Manchester were penalised as they attempted to clear and Jason Critchley gave Lions the lead with the simple kick.  ( 6 – 5 ). 

A Lions penalty for Manchester not binding properly at the scrum gave Jacques Steyne the opportunity to set up an attacking line-out.  This time the throw was good, and several phases of play drove the ball to the shadow of the Manchester posts where Jacques Steyne struck a sweet drop goal to extend Lions’ lead.  ( 9 – 5 ). 

Lions were now starting to wind things up and a sweeping move down the right involving James Baker, Phil Reed, and Tristan Prosser-Shaw almost saw the break.  As the ball was swung left, wing James Black almost got round his man but was just held.  The ball was slung back right and more good work by Matt Vines, this time in attack, almost had James Baker away, but the cover was good and the ball was lost in the tackle.  However, Manchester knocked on in trying to clear and Lions had an ideal attacking scrum.  There were all sorts of options…..a back row move, pushover…..so which option do Lions take??  They decide to bore in as the scrum is being set and concede a free kick……criminal or wot!?!?! 

Manchester cleared their lines and quickly established an attacking position as Lions were penalised for illegally stopping a powerful Manchester maul.  Marcus Barrow converted the simple kick.  ( 9 – 8 ). 

It was cut and thrust now, but as half time approached, Manchester started to turn the screw.  Surely Lions wouldn’t concede their customary try on the stroke of half time!?!?!  Ofcourse they would!!  A series of penalties and attacking line-outs had Lions defending desperately.  When Manchester were awarded an attacking scrum, Lions seemed powerless to prevent a score from a big push, but illegal play forced referee Alan Biggs to award a penalty try under the posts that Marcus Barrow easily converted as the whistle went for half time. 

Half time 

Lions   9          Manchester   15

 

Lions desperately needed an early score, but everything they threw at Manchester was easily soaked up by a resolute defence.  Rob Hurrell was again in fine form as he started to win some good possession for Lions.  A good chip and chase by James Baker, another player to enhance his reputation, set up an attacking Lions’ line-out.  Manchester were penalised 3 times in quick succession as they defended several Lions’ drives.  Eventually referee Alan Biggs said enough was enough and showed a yellow card to Manchester lock David Jessiman for illegal rucking. 

Unfortunately Lions could not capitalise on the immediate situation as their cumbersome attack made little inroads into a determined Manchester defence.  Lions should now have been pressing home their one man advantage, but it was Manchester who looked anything but a man short as they drove Lions back fully 30 metres with a well executed rolling maul. 

A rare incursion into Lions’ territory saw centre Craig Cooper stopped by a desperate cover, but Dave Muckalt was on hand to brush aside some ineffective Lions’ tackling to reach over and score.  Marcus Barrow pulled the simple conversion wide.  ( 9 – 20 ). 

Lions now needed to rally, and the powers that be decided fresh legs were required.  So we take off our most effective lock, Rob Hurrell……..why???????  Another silly penalty against Lions for joining the line late gave Manchester the chance to gain some respite, as Lions made wholesale changes in an attempt to gee up a flagging performance.  Props Richard Moore and Phil Greenbury were replaced by Glen Carson and Richard List, Ben Smith replaced the anonymous Ben Wheeler, and Sam Cole came onto the wing in place of James Black. 

A sweeping Lions’ move soon reaped dividends as James Baker cut in from his wing to take a well timed inside pass to race over.  Jason Critchley missed the conversion.  ( 14 - 20 ). 

Lions were looking a little more purposeful now as Stewart Potter took the ball at pace to almost punch a hole.  Lions old failings were all too evident as players became isolated in the tackle to surrender possession to Manchester, despite the best attempts of Tristan Prosser-Shaw who turned in a good second half performance. 

It was from one such turnover that Manchester attacked down the right, and as the cover snuffed out the danger, the ball was swung crossfield for wing Martin Worthington to cut inside three would be tacklers to score by the posts.  Marcus Barrow slotted the simple conversion.  ( 14 – 27 ). 

Lions now needed 2 scores with time running out, but a lack of application and the inevitable turnovers allowed Manchester to retain possession to the final whistle. 

 

Final result: 

 

Lions   14          Manchester   27

mmm

Lions are now firmly rooted at the foot of National Division 2 on equal points……sorry, point…..with Moseley who only managed to scrape a team together just before the start of the season when they were saved from extinction.  So what is going wrong? 

We have always tried to keep a positive approach to the Club on this site, but I’m afraid that today’s performance cannot pass without criticism.  I make no apologies if what I am about to say offends anyone. 

As we have said following previous matches, Lions look a totally disorganised outfit with no game plan.  We were promised that things would improve as the squad got used to each other, but instead we look to be going backwards as the team turned in their worst performance of the season. 

The forwards look in total disarray.  The line-out is a shambles, despite the best endeavours of the excellent Robbie Hurrell. Today we were marched back fully thirty metres by a 7 man Manchester pack, and could do nothing in response when given attacking opportunities.  It appears that application and passion are absent in equal measures. 

The on field coaching and off field management is simply not working.  Things are not going well on the field, so what do we do?  We replace our most effective forward Robbie Hurrell.  Given the choice of which lock to replace, I think Robbie would have been my second choice. 

Despite losing, we have scored some good tries in previous games, but today we just did not seem to have any idea of how to break down a stubborn Manchester defence……apart from once!!  We totally lack any sort of penetration and lines of running to vary the angle of attack are conspicuous by their absence.  Too often we see both forwards and backs taking the ball standing still.  Whatever happened to taking the ball at pace??  We did it once today, and Stewart Potter made yards……but sadly this seemed to take the rest of the team by surprise as he was left totally isolated and possession was lost.   

How many times did we see people being left in the same position today?  Too many to mention.  When Lions move the ball wide they look dangerous, especially with the speedy James Baker on the wing.  However, we inevitably seem to end up with players isolated that results in the inevitable turnover or penalty for not releasing.  Could it be that the forwards are simply not fit enough to keep pace? 

Then ofcourse we have the old failings of kicking possession away and giving silly penalties and free kicks.  Schoolboy stuff, but we seem incapable of learning…..or perhaps we do not have the right teachers. 

So where do we go from here?  Sadly there does not seem to be anywhere to go but down.  On today’s performance we have to accept that we are just not good enough for this Division.  Despite spending money on players, they are simply not performing.  If we are not careful, we will not only find ourselves being relegated, but could also find the club in a cash crisis.  We could well emulate West Hartlepool and find ourselves heading for oblivion in the junior ranks. 

So what is to be done?  Management and coaches need to take a long hard look at the situation.  Many people believe that money would be better spent on a good Director of Rugby and a top class Director of Coaching.  We should then get together a team of players who WANT to play for Lions.  It was good to see so many ex-Lions in the Clubhouse today who are no longer with the Club.  They obviously still have an affinity with the Lions.  We can all name other players who have given their all for the club, and would probably do so again……if the set up was right.  At the moment it obviously isn’t. 

If we don’t accept the inevitable now and start to muster a team together who will more than hold their own in Division 2 when the inevitable happens at the end of the season, we will be left with no team, no money, and no future.   

It was sad to hear ardent supporters in the Clubhouse after today’s game saying that they will not be spending good money travelling to away games to watch the shambles we have seen today. I’m not saying I have all the answers and it is easy to criticise.  However, it is obvious that things are not right at the Club and changes are desperately needed……and the sooner the better. 

What do you think?  Let’s hear your views on the Message Board

 
  

Match Preview

Lions team

by Dennis Keen

 

After three games played the same number of clubs in the division has failed to win any of them, Manchester, Moseley and Rugby. None of the clubs is completely pointless as Manchester and Moseley each have a losing bonus point and Rugby has a four-try point. The three are separated at the foot of the league table on the basis of points difference only, with Manchester on –38, Moseley on –72 and Rugby last with –132. Of the three, Rugby has so far faced the most difficult set of games, followed by Manchester, then Moseley who has not yet met a real promotion challenger. In order to remain in National Division 1 Rugby must secure a win in the home game against each of these two clubs, if not in the away games as well.  

Moseley, who visit Plymouth on Saturday, do not play The Lions in Rugby until 22nd February next year, but this coming Sunday it is Manchester’s turn to visit Webb Ellis Road. Last season’s home game against the Mancunians saw Rugby’s 25-5 halftime lead decay to 25-13 by full time, however, at the end of his match report Don Townend summed it up as follows.  

This was a fully deserved victory for Lions reflecting a committed performance by the whole team.  The 5 points secured lifts Lions above both Moseley and Manchester into mid-table.”  

Don would love to write this again as it would save him having to think of something else. So please make it happen Lions.

  

15 Matt Vines
14 James Black
13 Stuart Potter
12 Jason Critchley
11 James Baker
10 Jacques Steyn
9 Phil Reed
8 Tom Hayman
7 Tristan Prosser-Shaw (c)
6 Ben Wheeler
5 Rob Hurrell
4 Guy Manson-Bishop
3 Phil Grennbury
2 Matt Williams
1 Richard Moore
Reps  
  Glen Carson
  Richard List 
  Ben Smith
  Tim Stannard 
  Alex Taylor 
  Sam Cole
  James Bingham

 

 

 

 
Return to top of page