The Rugby Football Club

 

 Rugby Lions Supporters Site

 

      
Best viewed 1024x768    
Home
Forum
Fixtures
Match Reports
Players
Colts
Mini & Junior
Past Seasons
History
Membership Benefits
Supporters Club
Links
Directions
Contact Us
                         

 

                  

 
   

National Division 2

   
Rugby Lions 8 v 38 Harrogate
  on 27th September 2003, at Webb Ellis Rd, Rugby CV22 7AU  
   ko :  3.00pm  
         
 
 
Match Report
© RugbyLions.net.  Report by Don Townend, pictures Dave Rushall
 

They say it’s not over ‘till the fat lady sings.  Well, she was singing like a bird at half time as Harrogate wrapped this match up with 6 first half tries, including 4 from lineout drives that Lions simply had no answer to.  To highlight what might have been, the second half was scoreless, although it could be said that Gate had done enough to win the match by half time and could afford to ease off after the break. 

The writing was on the wall as early as the second minute.  Gareth Collins covered a Gate chip through, and Pig Brittin hacked the ball to touch as it squirmed from Gareth’s grasp, but was adjudged to have done so from an offside position.  Lee Cholewa tapped the penalty to the corner.  The line out was won with ease, and the Gate pack drove Paul Clark over from 10 metres as though the Lions’ 8 weren’t there.  Lee Cholewa’s conversion attempt drifted wide.  ( 0 – 5 ) 

Gate’s forward power was in evidence again from the kick off as they drove a rolling maul 30 metres……the only crumb of comfort for the Shed faithful was that when the pack eventually released the ball, the Gate backs immediately knocked on. 

Sam Stoop looked dangerous with a touchline run down the left, but his inside pass did not go to hand and Gate were soon back in Lions’ territory.  Another penalty allowed Lee Cholewa to put the ball to the corner, and another textbook take and drive saw Steve Hobson driven over in the same spot as the first try.  This time Lee Cholewa made no mistake with his conversion.  ( 0 – 12 ). 

Lions were seeing very little possession, and after 10 minutes the Gate pack were once again driving towards the Lions’ line.  This time Lions were penalised for taking the maul down, but respite was short lived as Lee Cholewa again put the ball to the corner.  This was now getting to be like Groundhog Day, as there was the inevitable take, the inevitable drive, and the inevitable score, this time by Mark Erven.  Lee Cholewa’s third conversion attempt from exactly the same place as the first two was wide.  ( 0 – 19 ) 

Now it was Lions’ turn to win a penalty as Gate strayed offside, and Jon Boden put his kick deep into Gate territory.  Unfortunately, Lions’ tale of woe continued as Gate took what was Lions’ first lineout put in, and cleared up field with ease.  Worse was to come, as a poor clearance kick allowed Gate’s Matt Duncombe to slice through Lions’ non-existent tackling to put Lee Cholewa under the posts for a simple score.  Cholewa also added the simple conversion.  ( 0 – 24 ) 

Lions were being starved of possession, and when they did get scraps, Gate were happy to concede penalties in the knowledge that they had total dominance at the line out and could secure possession at will. 

It was one of those days for Lions as they tried to get some semblance of order to their play, but everything they tried simply went wrong.  Planned moves saw the ball being spilled, chips ahead seemed to be attracted to Gate hands.  The situation was typified by a Sam Stoop penalty being planted behind the goal line, resulting in a Gate 22 metres drop out.  If Lions had a game plan at the start of the match, this had certainly gone out of the window by now. 

More inept play by Lions’ saw another penalty tapped to the corner by Cholewa……and you can guess the rest.  At least this score, by Mark Erven again, was on the opposite side to the first 3 tries, so the boredom factor was reduced.  Lee Cholewa added an excellent conversion from wide out.  ( 0 – 31 ) 

Lions' frustration was plain to see as Gate conceded penalty after penalty each time Lions managed to get any decent possession, and referee Richard Parker-Sedgemore chose to keep his yellow card firmly in his pocket.  Fed up with the situation, Jon Boden decided to go for goal with one of the penalties, and his 35 metres kick was straight and true to register Lions’ first points as half time approached.  (  3 – 31 ) 

But Gate, and Mr Kraper-Greedsome, were not finished yet, as the referee handed Gate a penalty try as they followed up a kick through that Lions had covered.  Lee Cholewa’s simple conversion followed.  ( 3 – 38 ) 

There was still time for Lions to regain some pride as Sam Stoop was prominent in two attacks as Lions enjoyed some rare quality possession to show just what might have been.  Then came the inevitable penalty, but with half time looming, the kick was planted in the corner.  This time Ben Smith rose to take the catch, and as Lions drove in, Danny Facer peeled off the maul to crash his way over.  Jon Boden’s conversion attempt was pushed wide as the charging Gate players almost reached him.  ( 8 – 38 ) 

Half time 

Lions    8          Harrogate          38

 

 
 

Danny Facer still with plenty to do

 

..but there was no stopping him

Despite using all 4 substitutes, with Matt Davies, Doun Du Preez, Phil Greenbury and Lloyd Warner replacing Pig Brittin, Danny Facer, Simon Black, and Alex Taylor, Lions were unable to add to their score in the second half.  The good news is that they also prevented Gate from adding to their score.   

Lions showed much more purpose and organisation in the second half, and there were glimpses of the rugby that they are capable of playing when they can secure decent possession.  Sam Stoop had a couple of counter attacks from Gate kicks, and a score should really have come from one of these, but Sam chose to pass inside to the supporting Spencer Brown when he could probably have made the corner.  Unfortunately the pass did not go to hand.   

Then Spencer Brown superbly fielded a high kick under pressure right on the touchline, spinning away from would be tacklers to scythe through the centre of the Park defence and almost put Gareth Collins in at the corner, but the Park cover just prevented the score. 

Again Gate reverted to penalties to try to stop Lions, and at last the referee saw fit to issue a yellow card to Gate lock Paul Clark.  However, Lions could not capitalise on their numeric superiority, although a brilliant Pete Roberts break from inside his own 22, followed by excellent interplay between forwards and backs deserved a score……but again the Gate defence held firm, albeit with the help of some rather high tackles that Mr Parker-Domegrees deemed to be perfectly legal.   

But hey, let’s not make this sound like sour grapes.  Lions were well and truly beaten by a better side……whether they were 30 points better is another debate, but just look at the score. 

Final result: 

Lions    8          Harrogate          38

 

Don's musing 

I said last week that we were on a roll, and Judgie said that he would prefer to call it a baguette as it was bigger.  Oh dear, Lions were living on crumbs today, and simply had no answer to the power of the Gate pack.  After suffering a similar fate at Bracknell, I criticising players for standing off the maul, Mal Malik responded by saying that it is a matter of technique rather than numbers.  Unfortunately we do not seem to have mastered the technique yet…….something that the forwards’ coaches need to work on as a matter of urgency. 

Lineout possession was another worry today, but with Chris Jones and Steve Smith both injured, at least there is some light at the end of the tunnel when both of these are fit to return.  That will pose some interesting selection issues, with Phil Skillen and Ben Smith working well at flanker, and Eddie Simkiss proving to be a revelation at number 8.  The joys of being a selector.   

Despite all this, I am still confident that Lions have the team and the spirit to more than survive in this League.  

Talking about selection, what about next week when there is “relief” from League action and we can enjoy ourselves in the cup against Exeter!?!?!  With the important league game against Nuneaton looming the following week, it must be tempting to do a Sedgely Park and field a weakened side.  However, getting the team to play as a unit is another driver, and the more match practice they can get together, the better.  Interesting times!!


 
Man of the match
 

Phil Skillen & Eddie Simkiss

 

 
  
Match preview  Team news
by Denis Keen
 

Although both the Harrogate and Rugby football clubs were founded over 130 years ago their history as opponents on the field only reaches back to the 1960s. Since that time there has been a total of 39 games played between the two sides: Rugby have won 23 of them, Harrogate have won 15 and one game was drawn.  

Rugby are well ahead with league successes, however, with seven wins out of the eight games played. Rugby’s highest league score against Gate is 27 and Gate’s highest against Rugby is 19. The average margin of victory for Rugby is a mere eight points and comfortable wins have been few.  Gate started this season with a 21-17 defeat at Sedgley Park but followed that with a comfortable 39-13 home victory against Stourbridge. Contrast that with Rugby’s similar margin of defeat at Bracknell and their narrow win at Doncaster and there is a recipe for yet another closely contested game in prospect for the coming weekend. 

Whether, as a Lions supporter, you are keen to see Rugby return to National Division 1, or you would be happier to see them as a regular “top fiver” in this division, there is no doubt that another home win today is important in the pursuit of both of these two aims. It would also set things up nicely for next Saturday’s sterner contest in the Powergen Cup third round home game against National Division 1 Exeter.

 

 

 
15   Sam Stoop  
14   Gareth Collins  
13   Peter Roberts  
12   Alex Taylor  
11   Spencer Brown  
10   Jon Boden  
9   Wimpie Jonker  
8   Eddie Simkiss  
7   Phil Skillen  
6   Danny Facer  
5   Ben Smith  
4   Steve Stewart  
3   Simon Black  
2   Jason Brittin  
1   Rhidian Booth  
Reps    
    Lloyd Warner  
    Matt Davies  
    Phil Greenbury  
    Gerbrand Du Preez  
 

Return to top of page

© RugbyLions.net - All rights reserved